More News

Immigration debate heats up weekend town hall

Congressman Jimmy Panetta responds to a resident’s call for a border wall.
Before speaking on immigration, resident Terry Clark said veterans should not pay a dime on health care. Photo by Noe Magaña.

After calmly covering topics that included veteran services, housing and infrastructure at a Saturday town hall hosted by Congressman Jimmy Panetta, emotions flared when talk turned to immigration.

During the April 13  gathering at the San Benito County Administrative Building on Fourth Street in Hollister, resident Terry Clark made clear his position on the border. He said despite being in favor of immigration, as he has family members from other countries, “what’s happening down there, the influx of everybody storming our borders right now needs to stop.”

Clark went on to say that because the government has not been able to get anything done for a long time, the situation is getting worse.

“So now there’s two or three more caravans coming up 100,000 people at a whack,” Clark said, adding that because immigrants get released about 20 days later they begin to collect welfare.

“I’m sick and tired of it,” Clark said. “Our schools are being ruined, our hospitals are being ruined. There’s got to be a time where this country stops.”

After receiving applause from one other resident among the roughly 20 people present, he said the American people will take matters into their own hands.

“We are going to go down to that damn border and we’re going to secure it ourselves because it’s disgusting what’s going on,” Clark said.

Panetta, who represents San Benito County and adjacent areas in the House of Representatives, responded by saying he believes decisions about having proper border security need to focus on policy and evidence rather than politics and slogans.

“It needs to be more than just a wall built all along the border,” Panetta said. “Unfortunately you have an administration that sold it as such. Unfortunately you have an administration that’s basically portraying the people who are coming here as out of a scene of a 1980s Chuck Norris movie where you’re having people in bell bottoms and t-shirts, guys running over and wanting to do harm and commit all this crime. That’s not it.”

Panetta said it’s not the nation’s economy pulling immigration, but rather a push-out of violence erupting in Central America.

“Yes, we are seeing chaos at our border because of the situation in Central America and building a wall is not going to stop them from continuing to come here,” Panetta said.

He said the solution is to hire more asylum officers and judges to process around 800,000 asylum applicants that exist right now.

“You have people showing up to your front door who basically got the crap beat out of them or are afraid,” Panetta said. “We don’t turn people away. One, that’s not the humane thing. Two, it’s not the American thing. Three, it’s not our law.”

Before discussions turned away from immigration, Clark said the country needs to deal with immigration the right way or the U.S. will turn into a third world country.

“If you people don’t think so, wait another 20 years,” Clark said. “Look at what California has  turned into. It’s pathetic.”

San Juan Bautista Councilman John Freeman quickly responded from the audience by saying  that as the sixth largest economy in the world, California is doing pretty well.

Before it turned into a bigger argument, Panetta stepped in and broke the tension by talking about the history of the United States.

“We’re not just a nation of immigrants,” Panetta said. “We are a nation of risk-takers. People who understand what it means to take risks. That’s how we succeed. We are also a humane nation. We also need to come up with a plan to deal with people at our borders who are looking to us, the beacon on the hill, as a place where they can go for salvation. To get away from violence.”



BenitoLink Logo

Become a Member Today

Support your local independent news.

We work hard to give you the news and information you need. By becoming a member, you will be part of something bigger; BenitoLink, your community-supported news source.


Noe Magaña's picture
Noe Magaña (Noe Magaña)

Noe Magaña is a freelance writer for BenitoLink. He also experiments with videography and photography. A San Benito High School graduate with a bachelor's in journalism from San Jose State and a Liberal Arts Associate's Degree from Gavilan College. Noe also attended San Jose City College and was the managing editor for the City College Times, the school's newspaper. He also was a reporter and later a copy editor for San Jose State's Spartan Daily.


donpidd's picture
Submitted by Don Pidd (donpidd) on

Border walls and violence are reactions, NOT solutions.  The so-called immigration "crisis" can only be resolved with thoughtful, humane, and intelligent solutions that deal with the economic, social, political, and legal issues that have resulted in this fear and hate filled rhetoric that has so easily filled our easily manipulated minds. ALL asylum seekers have the legal right to be heard and find solace in America the Great so we don't have to be great again, we need to be GREAT NOW!; not with hatred, fear and violence, but with adherence to the principals that our founders fostered. Remember, we are a nation of laws and in the words of Abraham Lincoln, "Let every man remember that to violate the law is to trample on the blood of his father, and to tear the charter of his own and his children's liberty." So push your representatives to seek a clear and humane immigration policy NOW, otherwise you are just part of the problem and, sadly, not a patriotic part of the solution.

Submitted by (Robert Gilchris...) on

Don Pidd is entitled to his opinion. Jimmy Panetta is entitled to his. I voted for Donald Trump. I will vote for Donald Trump in 2020. Why? Because I have illegal immigrants living across the street from me, and because they are NOT wonderful. 

Submitted by (BJM) on

I have American born neighbors across the street who are NOT wonderful, but there is a lovely Hispanic family right next door. And i PRAY Pres Twitter isn't allowed to embarrass our country any further. Biden 2020

donpidd's picture
Submitted by Don Pidd (donpidd) on

I clearly get where you are coming from.  It's not about American values, humane treatment at the border, national security, economic realities, drug reform, prison reform, judicial improvement, etc., etc.; it's about NIMBY!...I hope your grandchildren appreciate your concerns. Also, if you truly believe Trump is a good president, I hope you read the Mueller report in it's entirety. This is not the person I volunteered to support when I went to Vietnam and fought for my (and your) country. I love my country and its founding values and, hopefully, you will be able to see past your immediate needs. Yes...that is my opinion!!!!

Immigration has been a hot topic for decades. Democrats especially hate the idea of a new immigration policy. From 2008 through 2010 they owned Congress, both the House with Nancy in charge and the Senate with Harry Reid in charge. They had a newly elected Democrat as President. And yet, they passed no immigration reform laws. It was a hot potato that they would not touch. You never heard from the Democrats until they knew that a Democrat-initiated immigration policy would not pass Congress. Now Jimmy wants something done...until Nancy puts the muzzle on him for the next election. Mr Trump will sweep the vote if a liberal reform is introduced now.

--William McCarey

Submitted by (Robert Gilchris...) on

We don't need comprehensive immigration reform. We don't need ANY immigration reform. We DO need enforcement of current laws! NO collusion! NO obstruction! NO communists! TRUMP 2020!

Add new comment

Add Facebook comment

Comment using your Facebook account. Facebook comments will be published on this page, and on Facebook. It will not be posted to the "Recent Comments" list on the BenitoLink front page.